Widow’s Bay – Review

Title: Widow’s Bay

Language: English

Episodes: 10

Where to Watch: Apple TV

Genres: Horror, Historical, Mystery, Folklore

Objectionable Content: Violence, Fear

Synopsis (from IMDB): A skeptical mayor leads the superstitious residents of a cursed New England island.


My Review of Widow’s Bay

I don’t normally compare things like TV shows or books, to other properties like “this is like this meets this!” or say things like “if you love this, then you’ll love this!” However, in this case, I’m kind of going to do that. Widow’s Bay makes me think of Jaws with the creep factor of From. No, there isn’t a killer shark stalking people who dare to swim in the ocean, but there is a Mayor trying to bring more tourism to his small town despite knowing that town isn’t safe. The island of Widow’s Bay is cursed, no one born there can leave. If they try, they’ll die. Not that the Mayor believes this. He thinks is all superstitious bullshit. That is, until he starts experiencing things that shouldn’t be real.

This show has such an amazing creep factor. It’s not full of jump scares but it has this undertone of dread throughout where you can’t really look away from the screen. And it’s the type of show that you don’t want to look away from because you might miss some little detail. I feel like Widow’s Bay could be very rewatchable because of that. There’s probably all sorts of little details that are missed on a first viewing and once those details are noticed it could change your entire perspective on the show.

I really like how the story is told mostly from the perspective of a skeptic, Tom, the Mayor. He claims he doesn’t really believe any of the superstitions, but deep down he must believe it to some degree. Otherwise, he would have let his son leave the island a long time ago. Tom, himself, wasn’t born on the island but his father was, so Tom can leave at any time. His wife, however, was born on the island. She tried to leave before giving birth to their son and ended up dying not long after.

There is almost no sexual content in this show, which is fairly unusual these days. There is violence but it’s not gratuitous. No gore just for the sake of gore. This show relies more on atmosphere to creep it’s audience out.

I can’t say that there was anything in particular I didn’t like about Widow’s Bay. There wasn’t anything that made me feel lost or like I was missing something. Yes, there is a lot of mystery here, but it was never one of those “that doesn’t make sense” kind of moments.

The cast of characters are all pretty interesting. Early on I felt sorry for Patricia, but as the show went on she just became a badass and I loved it. Some definite meta humor going on here.

I’m really excited for the next season, which is slated for 2027 though an exact release date has not been announced as of the time of this writing. I will keep my eye on that. Hopefully it’s not too late in the new year that it comes out.

My rating for Widow’s Bay is 5 out of 5 stars and I recommend it to anyone who loves a good creepy show, with a mystery based in folklore.

Have you watched Widow’s Bay? I’d really love to know what you thought of it too!

Thanks for reading!

Leave a Reply